Broadway in Crisis: A Timeline
From the 1918 flu to COVID-19 — every time the lights went dark, and how they came back on
The Pattern of Darkness and Light
Broadway has gone dark six times in its modern history. Each closure was predicted to be fatal. Each time, the theatre survived — changed, diminished in some ways, expanded in others, but alive. This timeline traces the pattern.
1918–1919: The Spanish Flu
Duration: ~4 weeks (intermittent) Shows running: ~30 Impact: Selective closures; theatres that stayed open saw 40–60% attendance dropsNew York City Health Commissioner Royal Copeland controversially refused to close theatres entirely, arguing that well-ventilated buildings were safer than crowded tenements. Some producers closed voluntarily; others performed to near-empty houses. The Actors' Equity Association, founded just five years earlier in 1913, had no mechanism to protect performers.
Recovery: Immediate. The 1919–20 season saw record openings.1919: The Actors' Equity Strike
Duration: 30 days (August 7 – September 6) Shows affected: All Broadway productions Impact: Complete shutdown; first labor action in Broadway historyActors demanded basic protections: payment for rehearsal time (then unpaid), limits on unpaid extra performances, and recognition of Equity as their union. Producers, organized as the Producing Managers' Association, refused. Chorus members — the most exploited workers in the theatre — were the strike's backbone.
The strike was settled when producers recognized Equity and agreed to a standard contract. This remains the foundational document of professional American theatre.
Recovery: The 1919–20 season opened late but strong.1975: The Near-Death of Times Square
Duration: Chronic (1970s–early 1990s) Context: Fiscal crisis, crime, pornography industry colonization of 42nd StreetNot a single closure event but a slow strangulation. By 1975, Times Square was synonymous with danger, decay, and sex shops. Legitimate theatres operated behind locked doors. Audiences — especially tourists and suburbanites — stayed away. Broadway's total gross in 1975 was $57 million (about $320 million in 2025 dollars, compared to $1.8 billion in the 2023–24 season).
A Chorus Line (1975) is often credited with saving Broadway. It did not — that required decades of urban policy, the Disney renovation of the New Amsterdam Theatre (1997), and Giuliani-era policing. But A Chorus Line proved that Broadway could still produce cultural events, and its 15-year run sustained the Shubert Organization through the leanest years.2001: September 11
Duration: 2 days (Broadway); weeks to months (tourism recovery) Shows running: 28 Impact: Immediate closure; slow recovery over 6 monthsBroadway closed on September 11 and reopened on September 13 — one of the fastest turnarounds in any cultural sector. But the tourism collapse was devastating. Shows that depended on tourist audiences (The Producers excepted) saw 30–50% drops. Several marginal shows closed immediately.
The recovery was aided by two factors: the "I Love New York" campaign's theatre component, and an outpouring of solidarity attendance. New Yorkers who hadn't been to Broadway in years went as an act of civic defiance.
2020–2021: COVID-19
Duration: 18 months (March 12, 2020 – September 14, 2021) Shows running: 31 (at closure) Impact: Longest shutdown in Broadway history; existential financial crisisThe COVID closure was unprecedented in duration and devastating in impact. Every running show suspended operations. Thousands of performers, musicians, stagehands, ushers, and box office workers lost their income simultaneously. Several shows — Frozen, Mean Girls, Beetlejuice (initially) — announced permanent closure.
The reopening, beginning September 14, 2021, with Springsteen on Broadway and Pass Over, was cautious: proof of vaccination required, masks mandatory, capacity initially limited. The 2021–22 season grossed $1.4 billion — remarkable given the restrictions, but still below pre-pandemic levels.
What the Pattern Reveals
Every crisis produces the same three-phase response:
- Panic: The industry declares itself mortally wounded
- Adaptation: New economic models, new audience strategies, new art
- Transformation: Broadway survives, but as a different version of itself
The post-COVID Broadway is not the pre-COVID Broadway. Ticket prices are higher. Running costs are higher. The number of new shows opening per season has declined. But attendance has recovered to ~85% of 2018–19 levels, and the cultural centrality of Broadway — challenged by streaming, gaming, and social media — has if anything increased.
The lights, it seems, always come back on.
Also in The Journal
